Bank jobs, finance jobs, recruitment in the financial markets, accounting and investment banking. Find jobs, post resumes and browse job market news

Join the debate

Search

  • formNewsSearch
Post your resume

 

Print

Is it morally wrong for banks to pay big bonuses this year?

6 October 2009

The government is looking to curb them as soon as possible, while banks want to pay the performers who bring in the profits, but is it morally wrong to pay big bonuses so soon after being bailed out from the brink of disaster?

Alistair Darling seems intent on ensuring bonus payouts are scaled back before the FSA proposals come into affect in 2010, and Lord Myners is meeting with international investment banks this week to try and convince them to toe the line.

But while onerous regulation is one way of clamping down on bonuses, both men are hoping that banks will feel morally compelled to scale back payments this year anyway.

"Yes, they can wait for legislation if they want. But I really think that some of them should show some common sense. They shouldn’t be paying this amount out in extravagant bonuses," said Darling last week at the Labour Party conference.

Meanwhile, in an interview with Financial News, Myners said: "There is no denying that issues around bonuses in particular are a source of considerable national anger and, whilst our banks continue to draw upon significant state support, either through funding or the implicit guarantee that banks have, then it seems odd for companies to be paying out very substantial bonuses or substantial dividends.”

So, the message is fairly clear – you can pay big bonuses this year, but should you? Bonuses have always been a part and parcel of banks' compensation practices, but is it morally correct that they're paid out in 2010?

Your thoughts please…

Comments (7)

Does it matter what Dozy darling thinks? This socially and financially corrupt government is on its last legs.

View all comments

Comments (7)

  • Does it matter what Dozy darling thinks?  This socially and financially corrupt government is on its last legs. My concern is that Cameron may be too intent on becoming a Tony Blair reversal figure (i.e. Blue to washed out Red) and not recognise the serious issues that gratuitous regulation will cause.

    DE 06 Oct 2009

    RECOMMEND

    Answers ID
    89762
    Function To Call
    displaySignInMessage()
    Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator
    • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formhandler.cfm
    • D
    • 89762
    • displaySignInMessage()

  • The bank I'm at has not taken any government money and is having a great year so far, so I fully expect to be paid in proportion to the profits of myself, my desk and the bank this year. Where do morals come into it?

    I'm really pissed off at the whole anti-bonus screaming. The size of bonuses had zero to do with the crisis - the misalignment between term of risk and term of bonus payments did, so yes by all means defer the bonuses of people trading 30-year instruments, but what have high frequency traders got to do with any of that?

    If 'bonus culture' is a bad thing why don't we fight the 'salary culture' as well? What about footballers and pop stars' salaries, for example?

    EK 21 Oct 2009

    RECOMMEND

    Answers ID
    90473
    Function To Call
    displaySignInMessage()
    Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator
    • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formhandler.cfm
    • D
    • 90473
    • displaySignInMessage()

  • There is a diffference between taking risk and maing money on your own/the organizations own money, and doing it on highly leveraged OPIUM - other people's money - that multiplies profits and risks. Trading desks and traders have a very narrow focus. They miss the big picture -leave alone issues such as systemic risk.
    I don't think that Volker/King's suggestions for reintroduction of a neo Glass Steagal will work either, as leverage comes from offshore sources too. The price of leverage has to rise to prevent the easy profit/easy money - and risk be damned route.

    Bhaskar 25 Oct 2009

    RECOMMEND

    Answers ID
    90600
    Function To Call
    displaySignInMessage()
    Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator
    • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formhandler.cfm
    • D
    • 90600
    • displaySignInMessage()

  • Is this a joke? I don't know where you live, but clearly it is on another planet. Forget the bonus. Do you not realize that millions of people are out of work because of the transgressions of Wall Street? Obviously, you have no family or friends that have been impacted by the recession or you would not make such an idiot comment. Arrogance like this make it understandable why Main Street hates Wall Street. Clearly, this is not your problem. Take your bonus. I dare you to donate 1 even 5% for some more deserving than yourself.

    Andrea 09 Dec 2009

    RECOMMEND

    Answers ID
    92823
    Function To Call
    displaySignInMessage()
    Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator
    • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formhandler.cfm
    • D
    • 92823
    • displaySignInMessage()

  • What is morally right today? Have gun, go west !

    gerardo 13 Dec 2009

    RECOMMEND

    Answers ID
    92997
    Function To Call
    displaySignInMessage()
    Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator
    • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formhandler.cfm
    • D
    • 92997
    • displaySignInMessage()

  • who gives 5hit! I go where the money goes. If this Government does not like it, it can go take a jump, preferably into shark infested water.

    David 05 Jan 2010

    RECOMMEND

    Answers ID
    93470
    Function To Call
    displaySignInMessage()
    Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator
    • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formhandler.cfm
    • D
    • 93470
    • displaySignInMessage()

  • Sorry Andrea but why did main street keep buying overinflated houses?

    Sule 06 Jan 2010

    RECOMMEND

    Answers ID
    93495
    Function To Call
    displaySignInMessage()
    Recommended 0 times | Alert Moderator
    • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formhandler.cfm
    • D
    • 93495
    • displaySignInMessage()

Add your comment

* Mandatory

You have 1200 characters left

Enter the code shown here or sign in / register to skip this step. (What is this?)

  • formAnswers
  • http://news.eFinancialCareers.dk/formHandler.cfm?actionTemplate=myAccount

Post comment

  • Insert your comment here (under 1200 characters)
Col3
Col4
Col5
Col6
bottom

Site Information

eFinancialCareers is a Dice Holdings, Inc. company. Dice Holdings, Inc. is a publicly traded company listed on the New York Stock Exchange (Ticker: DHX)